The Only Cause of Disease: Healing by Reversing Pathology — Chapter 21 — Treating Osteoporosis

Chapter 21 — Treating Osteoporosis

The Only Cause of Disease: Healing by Reversing Pathology — Thomas E. Levy, MD, JD

Part 1 of 2; physical source pages 441–446.

Book introduction and complete contents · Previous section · Next section · Next part

Editorial notice — separate from the source: This is a faithful reproduction of the author’s published source, not an I-OM clinical guideline or endorsement of every claim. It is educational material, not individualized medical advice. The source’s original disclaimers and copyright notices are retained. Safety note: Do not use this reproduction as instructions for self-treatment. Hydrogen peroxide mist can irritate the respiratory tract; higher exposures can cause serious lung injury. See CDC/ATSDR safety guidance.

Unchanged original PDF


Source page 441

Open original page 441 — full-size image

Chapter 21 Repetition does not transform a lie into a truth. Franklin D. Roosevelt

Treating Osteoporosis

Treatment Overview Although it is one of the most popular supplements in the world today, calcium should never be taken in supplemental form. Anyone with any disease already has too much calcium inside the affected cells, and supplemental calcium will only work to sustain and even further increase cellular calcium levels and intracellular oxidative stress. The permissible amount of dietary calcium is less restrictive, especially when blood vitamin D3 levels are normal. Nevertheless, dairy sources of calcium should be minimized. The restrictions on dairy mainly apply to the water-sol- uble components of milk and the products derived from these components. However, the fat-soluble portions of milk have significant nutritional value and relatively small amounts of calcium. Dairy products, such as butter and cream, can be ingested without any significant concerns regarding calcium content. 441

Source page 442

Open original page 442 — full-size image

442 THE ONLY CAUSE OF DISEASE

Calcium supplementation alone does not strengthen osteopo- rotic bone and make it less susceptible to fracture. On the other hand, properly dosed vitamin D3 improves bone quality while decreasing the chances of osteoporotic fractures. Total calcium intake (dietary and supplemental) increases all-cause mortality in patients with the highest intake levels compared to those with the lowest intake levels. Supplements that help to lower and optimize calcium levels inside cells and decrease all-cause mortality include vitamin C, magnesium, vitamin D3, and vitamin K2.

Osteoporosis: Focal Scurvy of the Bones As described in Chapter 1, all disease is characterized by inflammation, meaning a advanced vitamin C deficiency, in the affected tissues. Focal scurvy is an accurate description of the pathophysiology of any area with sufficiently increased oxidative stress. This vitamin C deficiency in osteoporotic bone is well-sup- ported by the following points established in the literature: ✓ A chronic state of inflammation in the body, as reflected in increased C-reactive protein levels, reliably predicts an increased risk of osteoporotic fractures in elderly women. 1-2 ✓ Increased levels of other inflammatory parameters also correlate with an increased risk of fractures. 3-4 ✓ High doses of vitamin C have been shown to significantly reduce elevated levels of C-reactive protein and other markers of inflammation. 5-7 ✓ Osteoblasts, the bone-forming cells, are stimulated to develop from precursor cells by vitamin C. 8

Source page 443

Open original page 443 — full-size image

Treating Introduction Osteoporosis 443

✓ The precursor cells from which osteoblasts develop are stimulated to proliferate by vitamin C. 9 ✓ Vitamin C is essential for the formation of the type of collagen required for the accelerated growth of osteoblasts. 10 ✓ Osteoclasts, the bone-destroying cells, are inhibited by vitamin C. 11 ✓ Net bone mass loss, accompanied by demineralization and loss of integrated calcium, is accelerated when vitamin C levels become sufficiently depleted. 12 ✓ The cross-linking of bone collagen (comprising 90% of the bone matrix protein) required for structural strength is stimulated by vitamin C. 13 ✓ Vitamin C, in the All the measures absence of calcium that are effective in supplementation, helping to reverse resulted in significantly osteoporosis work greater bone mineral to decrease the density at all bone sites oxidative stress in tested. 14 This indicates the affected bones, that the improvement while supplying the in density involved all most appropriate the elements needed to form healthy bone, agents and building without the misleading blocks to build cosmetic effect caused by new bone. calcium supplementation in this test. ✓ In mice with ovaries removed, vitamin C administration prevented the bone loss

Source page 444

Open original page 444 — full-size image

444 THE ONLY CAUSE OF DISEASE

that would otherwise occur. This indicates that vitamin C is a bone-building agent, providing bone protection comparable to that afforded by normal estrogen levels. 15

Osteoporosis Reversal All the measures that are effective in helping to reverse osteo- porosis work to decrease the oxidative stress in the affected bones, while supplying the most appropriate agents and building blocks to build new bone. Agents that actively work in osteoporosis reversal, as well as in maintaining healthy bone, include the following:

Vitamin C ✓ Osteoporosis is bone scurvy. See above for supporting data. ✓ Decreases bone resorption while increasing bone synthesis ✓ Highest vitamin C levels correlate with the lowest risk of fracture ✓ Decreases all-cause mortality ✓ No established toxic levels of intake

Magnesium ✓ A calcium channel blocker that also works to dissolve abnormal calcium deposits 16-18 ✓ Increases bone density and decreases fracture incidence 19 ✓ Decreases all-cause mortality 20-21 ✓ No significant toxicity

Source page 445

Open original page 445 — full-size image

Treating Introduction Osteoporosis 445

Vitamin K ✓ Activates proteins that inhibit ectopic calcification 22 ✓ Works to dissolve abnormal calcium deposits 23 ✓ Improves bone quality and decreases fracture incidence 24-26 ✓ Decreases all-cause mortality 27 ✓ No significant toxicity 28

Vitamin D ✓ Normal vitamin D levels help ensure normal calcium absorption from the diet. ✓ Critical for regulating numerous genes 29 ✓ Deficiency causes osteoporosis 30 ✓ Excess worsens osteoporosis 31 ✓ Key determinant of bone mineral density in reaching maturation 32 ✓ In the therapeutic range, decreases all-cause mortality 33-34

Essential Fatty Acids ✓ Some with calcium channel blocking activity 35-36 ✓ Afford protection against loss of bone mineral density 37-38 ✓ Higher blood levels, less mortality 39 ✓ No significant toxicity

Estrogen ✓ A calcium channel blocker that works to inhibit ectopic calcification 40-42 ✓ Decreases fracture incidence 43 ✓ Deficiency increases all-cause mortality 44

Source page 446

Open original page 446 — full-size image

446 THE ONLY CAUSE OF DISEASE

Testosterone ✓ A calcium channel blocker that works to inhibit ectopic calcification 45-46 ✓ Deficiency increases fracture risk 47 ✓ Deficiency increases all-cause mortality 48-49

Thyroid Hormone ✓ Necessary for early skeletal development and the establishment of peak bone mass 50 ✓ High and low thyroid function increases fracture risk 51 ✓ Minimally high thyroid function and minimally low thyroid function are risk factors for increased all-cause mortality 52-53

Practical Suggestions When deciding on the for Calcium Intake healthiest amounts of calcium to ingest In large part, the marketing and considering efforts of the dairy industry have the likelihood that dictated the recommended daily too much calcium intake of calcium. Rarely have these is already present recommendations been seriously inmost adult bodies, challenged. Instead, they have just been accepted as true. the different causes of excess calcium The medical literature has an presence need to be abundance of studies on calcium taken into account. intake and the incidence of different chronic degenerative diseases, espe- cially heart disease and cancer. Even in extensive studies, many of the results and conclusions are in complete contradiction to one another. However, a consistent finding among these studies is that lower amounts of dietary


Book introduction and complete contents · Previous section · Next section · Next part

Chapter 21 — Treating Osteoporosis

The Only Cause of Disease: Healing by Reversing Pathology — Thomas E. Levy, MD, JD

Part 2 of 2; physical source pages 447–450.

Book introduction and complete contents · Previous section · Next section · Previous part

Unchanged original PDF


Source page 447

Open original page 447 — full-size image

Treating Introduction Osteoporosis 447

calcium can be beneficial, while higher amounts of dietary calcium can support disease. There is also uncertainty regarding the potential harm of calcium supplementation, although there is general agreement that excessive daily intake of calcium supplements can provoke and exacerbate chronic disease. 54-65 While calcium can undoubtedly be considered a nutrient, it is not a nutrient in the traditional sense of the word. Most calcium supplementation is given with the idea of slowing or reversing oste- oporosis. In otherwise healthy, mature bones, a minimal amount of calcium is required to participate in the ongoing synthesis and breakdown that occurs in their active physiology. It is generally accepted that the need for calcium is greater in young, actively growing bone than in adult bone. When considering how much new calcium needs to be assimilated daily, it is essential to remember that older adults, especially women, are already actively releasing large amounts of calcium continuously as part of the general bone deterioration and increased rate of oxidation asso- ciated with osteoporosis and aging. This is never factored into determining the amount of daily calcium exposure/intake the body needs. When deciding on the healthiest amounts of calcium to ingest and considering the likelihood that too much calcium is already present in most adult bodies, the different causes of excess calcium presence need to be taken into account. The more of these factors that are present and pronounced, the greater the chances that significant calcium excess is already present, that calcifications already exist throughout the body, even if not detected, that intra- cellular calcium levels are already elevated, and that even less new calcium needs to be ingested. These causes include:

Source page 448

Open original page 448 — full-size image

448 THE ONLY CAUSE OF DISEASE

✓ Excess calcium intake (supplementation and/or diet) ✓ Excess calcium mobilization from the bones (osteoporosis and osteopenia) ✓ Deficiencies of vitamin C and other essential antioxidants ✓ Excess toxin presence, especially from sites of chronic infection and inflammation. ✓ Deficiencies of critical regulatory hormones (especially sex hormones, thyroid, and cortisol) ✓ Deficiencies, especially of magnesium, vitamin D3, and vitamin K2 The best way to assure a “normal” daily intake of calcium in the diet is to eat a reasonably balanced diet with minimal dairy, while maintaining a normal vitamin D3 level (50 to 100 ng/cc) in the blood. Vitamin D3 helps optimize appropriate calcium absorp- tion from the diet while facilitating the optimal incorporation of calcium into new or healing bone. The importance of vitamin D3 in normalizing calcium and bone metabolism comes from several studies showing that vitamin D3 supplementation alone (at a dose of 800 or more IU daily) resulted in fewer fractures in osteoporotic patients. In contrast, calcium supplementation alone did not prevent fractures. 66-72 In one study, a small dose (400 IU) of vitamin D3 and a relatively large amount of calcium (1,000 mg elemental) did not reduce the likelihood of hip fractures. Still, they did increase the risk of kidney stones. 73 The combination of calcium and vitamin D3 was also found to increase the risk of cardiovascular events. 74 Furthermore, much of the “literature support” for giving calcium for fracture preven-

Source page 449

Open original page 449 — full-size image

Treating Introduction Osteoporosis 449

tion comes from studies that gave BOTH calcium and vitamin D3. However, in the conclusions of these studies, it was merely asserted that calcium prevented fractures, completely ignoring the fact that vitamin D3 was also being adminis- tered. It appears that the researchers felt pressure to conclude that calcium The importance prevents fractures, leading to a of vitamin D3 in flawed conclusion that overlooked normalizing calcium the presence of vitamin D3 in the and bone metabolism protocols. Evidence also suggests comes from several that combining calcium supplemen- studies showing tation with vitamin D3 supplementa- that vitamin D3 tion increases the risk of kidney stone supplementation formation. 75 alone (at a dose of 800 or more IU So, what should be ingested and daily) resulted in what should not be eaten? Milk has fewer fractures in fat-soluble and water-soluble portions. osteoporotic patients. It is best to minimize the intake of dairy products derived from the water-soluble portion, which has the highest calcium content (milk, cheese, yogurt). More practically, the main emphasis would be to avoid milk as a beverage and consume small portions of cheese and yogurt a few times a week. Ironically, skim milk is the worst, since the fat is largely removed. Skim milk has the least nutrition and the most calcium that the milk has to offer. Alternatively, the fat-soluble portion of milk contains the portion that is nutrient-rich and calcium-poor. Sour cream, heavy cream, and butter can be consumed as desired without concern for excess calcium intake. For the cereal consumers, dilute heavy cream (or heavy whipping cream) with one-third to one-half water or non-calcium-enriched plant milks (like rice milk) as a milk substitute to pour over the

Source page 450

Open original page 450 — full-size image

450 THE ONLY CAUSE OF DISEASE

cereal. Of course, the cereal should be organic or at least unadulter- ated (no added iron or sugar). Calcium as a supplement should be avoided altogether, unless the total daily supplemental amount is roughly 100 mg or less. Notably, antacids containing calcium carbonate (which is the case with most of them) should be avoided entirely. Unfortunately, calcium carbonate is exceptionally effective in quickly relieving the discomfort of an acidic stomach, which makes it difficult for many patients with frequent stomach upset to avoid. Supplements that need to be taken regularly to improve bone health and to help keep intracellular calcium levels at or near normal levels are: ✓ Vitamin C ✓ Magnesium ✓ Vitamin D3 ✓ Vitamin K2 Because of the ability of excess intracellular calcium to promote death from all causes, it is noteworthy that each of these four calcium-lowering supplements has been shown individually to reduce all-cause mortality. 76-82


Book introduction and complete contents · Previous section · Next section · Previous part