Rethinking Ketogenic Diets, Hormones, and Women’s Health
Beyond BHRT: The Missing Metabolic and Orthomolecular Foundations of Hormonal Health
Richard Z. Cheng, MD, PhD | October 2026 | Public Health Education
Editor’s Note This article was prepared in part as a scientific and educational foundation for the author’s presentation, “The Insulin–Cortisol–Vitamin C Axis: A Systems-Based Regulatory Framework,” at A4M LongevityFest 2026 (December 11–13, Las Vegas). The presentation is scheduled for December 12, 2026.
A4M LongevityFest 2026 — speaker announcement
The presentation will explore the interactions and interdependence among insulin regulation, cortisol-mediated stress responses, and vitamin C physiology through the proposed Insulin–Cortisol–Vitamin C (ICV) Axis, with implications for metabolic health, healthy aging, and particularly bioidentical hormone replacement therapy (BHRT) and women’s hormonal health.
A central theme is that low-carbohydrate/metabolic medicine and orthomolecular medicine provide essential physiological foundations for functional and longevity medicine. Hormonal optimization, including BHRT, should not be pursued in isolation from underlying metabolic and micronutrient status. This integrated perspective—“Beyond BHRT: The Missing Metabolic and Orthomolecular Foundations of Hormonal Health”—reflects a core principle of Integrative Orthomolecular Systems Medicine (I-OM): lasting health requires coordinated attention to metabolic, nutritional, and hormonal regulation.
Preprint source: “Ketogenic and Intermittent Ketogenic Diets in Women: Evolutionary Foundations, Metabolic Flexibility, Sex-Specific Physiology, and Applications of the Insulin–Cortisol–Vitamin C Framework” (October 20, 2026). https://www.preprints.org/manuscript/202610.1932. This narrative review has not undergone peer review.
If Women Must Eat Carbohydrates, How Did Humanity Survive Before Agriculture?
We frequently hear that women need carbohydrates to maintain healthy hormones, regular menstrual cycles, fertility, and reproductive health. Some even suggest that ketogenic diets are fundamentally unsuitable for women.
But is this biologically justified?
Consider human evolutionary history.
Modern humans have existed for approximately 300,000 years, while our evolutionary ancestors go back millions of years. Agriculture began only about 12,000 years ago.
For the overwhelming majority of human evolutionary history, people depended on hunting, fishing, and gathering rather than cultivated grains and modern processed foods.
Carbohydrate availability differed dramatically across environments. Tropical populations might have access to fruits, tubers, roots, and honey, while populations in colder environments or during certain seasons might have substantially fewer carbohydrate sources.
Yet human populations survived and reproduced.
Women conceived, carried pregnancies, gave birth, and breastfed long before agriculture became widespread.
This raises an important question:
If substantial dietary carbohydrate intake were universally essential for female reproductive health, how did women reproduce across environments where carbohydrate availability was limited?
This evolutionary argument does not establish that all prehistoric humans ate ketogenic diets. Archaeological and anthropological research demonstrates that carbohydrate-rich plant foods also contributed importantly to many ancestral diets.
What evolution demonstrates is something broader: humans developed considerable flexibility in obtaining and utilizing metabolic fuels.
And this flexibility exists in both women and men.
1. The Human Body Needs Glucose—but Not Necessarily Dietary Carbohydrates
Glucose is essential for several physiological functions. Red blood cells, for example, depend on glucose because they lack mitochondria.
However, glucose does not have to come directly from dietary carbohydrates.
The body possesses two remarkable metabolic adaptations.
Gluconeogenesis: Manufacturing Our Own Glucose
The liver and kidneys can manufacture glucose from substrates including lactate, glycerol, and certain amino acids.
This allows blood glucose to be maintained even when dietary carbohydrate intake is substantially reduced.
Ketogenesis: Using Fat-Derived Fuel
When carbohydrate availability decreases, the liver increases production of ketone bodies, primarily beta-hydroxybutyrate and acetoacetate.
These ketones serve as alternative fuels for the brain and other tissues.
During sustained nutritional ketosis, the brain can obtain a substantial proportion of its energy from ketones, reducing its requirement for glucose.
Importantly, women possess the same fundamental glucose-producing and ketone-utilizing pathways as men.
There are essential amino acids and essential fatty acids, but no established essential dietary carbohydrate in the same biochemical sense.
This does not mean that carbohydrate-containing foods lack nutritional value, nor does it establish that eliminating carbohydrates produces optimal health outcomes.
It does, however, challenge the claim that women inherently require substantial carbohydrate consumption simply because they are women.
2. Why Ketogenic Nutrition May Benefit Women’s Metabolic Health
Ketogenic diets substantially reduce dietary carbohydrate intake, encouraging greater reliance on fatty acids and ketones for energy.
In appropriately selected individuals, carbohydrate restriction may improve:
Blood glucose regulation.
Insulin resistance and associated metabolic abnormalities.
Appetite control and weight management.
Triglyceride levels.
Certain metabolic and reproductive features associated with insulin resistance.
These potential benefits are particularly relevant to women with polycystic ovary syndrome (PCOS), also described in emerging terminology as polyendocrine metabolic ovarian syndrome (PMOS).
PCOS is frequently associated with insulin resistance, elevated androgen activity, menstrual irregularities, and impaired ovulation.
Excess insulin can contribute to ovarian androgen production and alter sex-hormone regulation.
Reducing dietary carbohydrate intake can lower postprandial glucose exposure and insulin demand, potentially improving metabolic regulation.
Small clinical studies of ketogenic dietary interventions in women with PCOS have reported improvements in insulin resistance, body composition, and certain reproductive and hormonal measurements.
These findings are encouraging, although larger and longer clinical trials are needed to determine how much benefit derives specifically from ketosis rather than weight loss, calorie reduction, or other dietary changes.
Nevertheless, they provide an important counterargument to the assertion that ketogenic nutrition necessarily damages women’s hormonal health.
3. Must Women Remain in Ketosis Continuously?
Not necessarily.
An important concept discussed in the new preprint is intermittent ketogenic nutrition.
Instead of remaining in continuous nutritional ketosis, individuals might periodically alternate between ketogenic and less carbohydrate-restricted eating patterns.
The goal is to investigate metabolic flexibility—the ability to adapt fuel utilization according to nutritional and physiological conditions.
This may offer an alternative for individuals who find continuous strict ketogenic diets difficult to maintain.
For people with significant insulin resistance or type 2 diabetes, more sustained carbohydrate restriction may offer better short-term glycemic control, although medications and metabolic responses require monitoring.
In cancer, ketogenic diets are also being investigated as potential adjuncts to conventional treatment. However, improved cancer survival from ketogenic interventions has not been established in rigorous clinical trials, and cancer patients may be particularly vulnerable to weight loss and malnutrition.
Intermittent ketogenic nutrition remains a promising research hypothesis, not an established superior or universally safer dietary protocol.
Its frequency, duration, nutritional composition, and long-term health effects require further investigation.
4. Are Reported Ketogenic Side Effects Really Caused by Ketosis?
This question deserves greater scientific attention, especially in women.
Some women report fatigue, headaches, sleep disturbances, constipation, hair loss, menstrual changes, mood disturbances, or reduced exercise performance after beginning ketogenic diets.
These experiences are real and should not be dismissed.
But observing a symptom during ketosis does not automatically establish that ketosis itself caused the symptom.
Several overlapping factors deserve consideration.
A. Electrolyte Depletion and Dehydration
During the early stages of carbohydrate restriction, reduced insulin levels and changes in glycogen storage can increase renal sodium and water losses.
This may contribute to headaches, weakness, dizziness, muscle cramps, and fatigue.
Such effects may arise from altered fluid and electrolyte balance rather than a direct harmful effect of ketones.
However, sodium and electrolyte replacement should be individualized, particularly in people with kidney disease, heart failure, hypertension, or relevant medication use.
B. Micronutrient Deficiencies
A poorly formulated ketogenic diet may fail to provide sufficient vitamins and minerals.
For example:
Magnesium: Inadequate intake can contribute to fatigue, muscle cramps, and neuromuscular symptoms.
Iron: Iron deficiency is particularly relevant to menstruating women and can produce fatigue, hair loss, and impaired exercise tolerance.
Iodine and selenium: These nutrients are important for thyroid function, although excess supplementation can also cause harm.
B vitamins: Deficiencies may affect energy metabolism, neurological function, and general health.
Vitamin C: Essential for collagen synthesis, antioxidant defense, carnitine biosynthesis, and several other physiological processes.
A low-carbohydrate diet can be nutritionally adequate, but this depends on food selection and, where appropriate, individualized supplementation.
The important question is whether symptoms reflect ketosis, inadequate nutritional intake, or both.
C. Inadequate Calories and Protein
Many people spontaneously eat less after reducing carbohydrates.
While this can benefit weight management in some individuals, excessive energy restriction may create problems, particularly for lean or physically active women.
Low energy availability can disrupt reproductive hormone signaling, impair exercise recovery, and contribute to menstrual irregularities.
This is recognized in the literature on relative energy deficiency in sport.
Importantly, low carbohydrate availability may also have physiological effects independent of total calorie deficiency in some athletic settings.
Therefore, neither carbohydrate restriction nor inadequate caloric intake should be automatically excluded as a contributing factor.
A sustainable nutritional program must provide sufficient energy and appropriate protein.
D. Thyroid Function, Menopause, and Other Medical Conditions
Symptoms such as fatigue, cold intolerance, sleep disturbances, menstrual irregularities, and hair loss can arise from multiple causes.
These include thyroid disorders, iron-deficiency anemia, menopause-related hormonal changes, chronic illness, excessive exercise, medication effects, and sleep disturbances.
When symptoms appear during dietary changes, clinicians should investigate these possibilities rather than assuming one explanation.
E. Environmental Toxicants: An Underexplored Possibility
Certain persistent environmental pollutants accumulate in adipose tissue.
During substantial weight loss, circulating concentrations of some fat-stored pollutants can increase as adipose tissue is mobilized.
This raises a research question: Could changes in circulating environmental pollutants influence symptoms during major dietary and weight-loss interventions?
The possibility deserves investigation, particularly within systems-oriented research.
However, there is currently insufficient evidence to conclude that pollutant mobilization explains typical ketogenic-diet symptoms in women.
Nor does this observation establish a need for detoxification therapies.
Controlled research is necessary to determine whether changes in pollutant concentrations produce clinically meaningful effects.
F. Genuine Diet-Related Adverse Effects Must Also Be Recognized
Not every adverse effect has an alternative explanation.
Ketogenic dietary patterns can cause constipation and gastrointestinal complaints. Some individuals experience substantial elevations in LDL cholesterol or apolipoprotein B (ApoB).
Carbohydrate restriction may also reduce performance during certain high-intensity athletic activities.
And people using insulin, sulfonylureas, or SGLT2 inhibitors may face important medication-related risks.
The goal should not be to dismiss adverse effects, but to identify their actual causes.
A scientific approach investigates both the benefits and possible harms of ketogenic nutrition instead of assuming either universal safety or universal danger.
5. The Insulin–Cortisol–Vitamin C Axis: A Broader Explanation
One of the major themes in our Integrative Orthomolecular Systems Medicine (I-OM) research is that human metabolism cannot be understood by examining dietary carbohydrates alone.
Our previously published Insulin–Cortisol–Vitamin C (ICV) framework proposes a systems-level model integrating metabolic regulation, stress physiology, and micronutrient status.
The framework considers three interconnected components.
Insulin: Metabolic and Hormonal Regulation
Insulin regulates glucose handling, nutrient storage, and multiple processes affecting reproductive and metabolic health.
Insulin resistance can influence ovarian androgen production, sex-hormone-binding globulin, and other hormonal pathways.
Carbohydrate restriction may improve insulin-related parameters in selected individuals, especially those with insulin resistance.
Cortisol: Stress and Metabolic Adaptation
Cortisol participates in glucose production, stress adaptation, immune regulation, and energy mobilization.
Its effects depend on physiological context, including sleep, physical activity, nutritional status, illness, and psychological stress.
A woman following a nutritionally adequate ketogenic diet may respond differently from one combining severe energy restriction, inadequate recovery, and sustained physiological stress.
Vitamin C: Nutritional and Redox Support
Vitamin C supports antioxidant defense, collagen and carnitine synthesis, catecholamine production, and normal physiological function.
The ICV framework proposes that vitamin C status may influence aspects of metabolic and hormonal adaptation.
However, it remains a research hypothesis rather than a validated method for predicting ketogenic-diet outcomes, and evidence does not establish that high-dose vitamin C prevents reproductive disturbances caused by carbohydrate restriction.
The broader lesson is that dietary responses may depend on multiple interacting variables.
A person’s response to ketogenic nutrition may reflect insulin sensitivity, energy intake, stress physiology, nutrient adequacy, medication use, and underlying health—not carbohydrate consumption alone.
This systems-level perspective provides testable questions for future research.
Related scientific paper:
Cheng, R. Z., Levy, T. E., and Hunninghake, R. (2025). The Insulin–Cortisol–Vitamin C Axis: A Missing Regulatory Framework in Metabolic and Hormonal Homeostasis—A Narrative Review.
Read the ICV framework preprint: https://doi.org/10.20944/preprints202512.0217.v3
6. What About Pregnancy, Breastfeeding, and Older Women?
The absence of an essential dietary carbohydrate requirement does not establish universal ketogenic-diet safety.
Pregnancy involves substantial changes in maternal metabolism, fetal development, and nutritional requirements. Current evidence does not support routine ketogenic dieting during pregnancy or lactation without specialized clinical evaluation.
Likewise, children and adolescents have important nutritional requirements for growth and development. Therapeutic ketogenic diets are used for selected medical conditions under specialist supervision, but should not be generalized to all children.
In older women, carbohydrate restriction may help manage certain metabolic conditions. However, maintaining adequate protein, energy, micronutrients, and muscle mass is particularly important.
Women with eating disorders, certain inherited metabolic disorders, or complex medical conditions may need to avoid ketogenic diets or pursue different strategies.
Sex alone should not dictate carbohydrate requirements, but age, reproductive status, health conditions, and individual physiology matter.
7. What Does a Well-Formulated Ketogenic Approach Look Like?
For adults considering ketogenic nutrition, the emphasis should be on nutritional adequacy rather than carbohydrate restriction alone.
Important principles include:
Adequate calories and high-quality protein to maintain muscle and physiological function.
Appropriate sources of dietary fat, with attention to lipid responses and cardiovascular risk.
Sufficient vitamins, minerals, and electrolytes from food and, when clinically indicated, supplementation.
Monitoring metabolic health, symptoms, and medication requirements.
Individual adjustment based on reproductive status, physical activity, medical conditions, and tolerance.
Evaluation of persistent symptoms rather than automatically attributing them to ketosis—or dismissing them as harmless adaptation.
Ketone levels can confirm nutritional ketosis, but higher ketone levels do not necessarily mean better health outcomes.
For people using glucose-lowering medications, professional guidance may be necessary before substantial carbohydrate restriction.
8. The I-OM Perspective: Beyond the Carbohydrate Debate
The familiar debate is often framed too simply:
Do women need carbohydrates, or should women avoid them?
A better scientific question is:
How do we optimize women’s metabolic health while accounting for insulin regulation, energy availability, hormonal physiology, nutritional status, and individual responses?
Human evolution demonstrates considerable dietary and metabolic adaptability.
Biochemistry confirms that both women and men can produce glucose and utilize ketones.
Clinical research suggests that ketogenic diets may offer meaningful benefits for selected women, especially those with insulin resistance and PCOS.
At the same time, long-term outcomes, reproductive effects, cardiovascular safety, and the relative merits of intermittent versus continuous ketosis require further study.
The I-OM approach emphasizes identifying underlying contributors to metabolic dysfunction and creating nutritionally adequate, individually appropriate interventions.
This means avoiding two equally unscientific assumptions:
That women universally require high-carbohydrate diets for hormonal health.
That ketogenic nutrition is automatically safe or optimal for every woman.
Our working hypothesis is that nutritional adequacy, metabolic health, stress physiology, and individual circumstances may explain much of the variation in women’s responses to carbohydrate restriction.
That hypothesis deserves rigorous clinical testing.
9. Conclusion: Women Need Adequate Nutrition, Not Necessarily High Carbohydrate Intake
Women do not have a scientifically established, universal requirement for high dietary carbohydrate intake simply because they are women.
Their bodies possess the same fundamental mechanisms of gluconeogenesis, fat oxidation, and ketone utilization as those of men.
Ketogenic nutrition may provide metabolic advantages in selected populations, including women with insulin resistance and PCOS.
Furthermore, symptoms occurring during ketogenic dieting should prompt investigation of nutritional inadequacies, electrolyte disturbances, insufficient energy availability, medications, medical conditions, and other potential contributors.
But genuine diet-related harms must also be recognized.
The goal is not to pursue ketosis at any cost.
It is to support metabolic health, hormonal function, nutritional adequacy, and long-term well-being.
Women need glucose—but they do not necessarily need to eat carbohydrates to obtain it.
And perhaps most importantly:
Women’s metabolic health deserves better science than blanket dietary rules based on sex alone.
Scientific Sources and Further Reading
Featured research preprint
Cheng, R. Z. (2026). Ketogenic and Intermittent Ketogenic Diets in Women: Evolutionary Foundations, Metabolic Flexibility, Sex-Specific Physiology, and Applications of the Insulin–Cortisol–Vitamin C Framework.
Preprints.org, October 20, 2026.
https://www.preprints.org/manuscript/202610.1932
Related ICV framework publication
Cheng, R. Z., Levy, T. E., and Hunninghake, R. (2025). The Insulin–Cortisol–Vitamin C Axis: A Missing Regulatory Framework in Metabolic and Hormonal Homeostasis—A Narrative Review.
https://doi.org/10.20944/preprints202512.0217.v3
For clinical studies, scientific references, and detailed discussion of competing hypotheses and research limitations, readers are encouraged to consult the full preprint.
About OMNS Global
Orthomolecular Medicine News Service (OMNS) Global promotes scientific discussion and public education concerning orthomolecular medicine, nutrition, metabolic health, micronutrients, and integrative approaches to health and disease.
OMNS Global and the I-OM Systems Medicine community encourage critical examination of metabolic, nutritional, hormonal, and environmental factors that may influence human health.
Explore the I-OM Systems Medicine community: https://community.i-om.ai
Learn more about I-OM: https://i-om.ai
Medical disclaimer: This article is intended for scientific discussion and public education. It does not constitute individualized medical advice. Ketogenic diets may be unsuitable for certain individuals or require professional monitoring, particularly during pregnancy, lactation, childhood, or treatment with glucose-lowering medications.
Disclosure: Adapted from the author’s scientific preprint posted on MDPI-supported Preprints.org. The preprint has not undergone peer review. Do Women Really Need Carbohydrates?
Rethinking Ketogenic Diets, Hormones, and Women’s Health
Richard Z. Cheng, MD, PhD | October 2026 | Public Health Education
Editor’s Note This article was prepared in part as a scientific and educational foundation for the author’s presentation, “The Insulin–Cortisol–Vitamin C Axis: A Systems-Based Regulatory Framework,” at A4M LongevityFest 2026 (December 11–13, Las Vegas). The presentation is scheduled for December 12, 2026.
[image]
A4M LongevityFest 2026 — speaker announcement
The presentation will explore insulin regulation, cortisol-mediated stress responses, and vitamin C physiology in metabolic health and healthy aging. This article also contributes to the broader scientific discussion of Integrative Orthomolecular Systems Medicine (I-OM).
Preprint source: “Ketogenic and Intermittent Ketogenic Diets in Women: Evolutionary Foundations, Metabolic Flexibility, Sex-Specific Physiology, and Applications of the Insulin–Cortisol–Vitamin C Framework” (October 20, 2026). https://www.preprints.org/manuscript/202610.1932. This narrative review has not undergone peer review.
If Women Must Eat Carbohydrates, How Did Humanity Survive Before Agriculture?
We frequently hear that women need carbohydrates to maintain healthy hormones, regular menstrual cycles, fertility, and reproductive health. Some even suggest that ketogenic diets are fundamentally unsuitable for women.
But is this biologically justified?
Consider human evolutionary history.
Modern humans have existed for approximately 300,000 years, while our evolutionary ancestors go back millions of years. Agriculture began only about 12,000 years ago.
For the overwhelming majority of human evolutionary history, people depended on hunting, fishing, and gathering rather than cultivated grains and modern processed foods.
Carbohydrate availability differed dramatically across environments. Tropical populations might have access to fruits, tubers, roots, and honey, while populations in colder environments or during certain seasons might have substantially fewer carbohydrate sources.
Yet human populations survived and reproduced.
Women conceived, carried pregnancies, gave birth, and breastfed long before agriculture became widespread.
This raises an important question:
If substantial dietary carbohydrate intake were universally essential for female reproductive health, how did women reproduce across environments where carbohydrate availability was limited?
This evolutionary argument does not establish that all prehistoric humans ate ketogenic diets. Archaeological and anthropological research demonstrates that carbohydrate-rich plant foods also contributed importantly to many ancestral diets.
What evolution demonstrates is something broader: humans developed considerable flexibility in obtaining and utilizing metabolic fuels.
And this flexibility exists in both women and men.
1. The Human Body Needs Glucose—but Not Necessarily Dietary Carbohydrates
Glucose is essential for several physiological functions. Red blood cells, for example, depend on glucose because they lack mitochondria.
However, glucose does not have to come directly from dietary carbohydrates.
The body possesses two remarkable metabolic adaptations.
Gluconeogenesis: Manufacturing Our Own Glucose
The liver and kidneys can manufacture glucose from substrates including lactate, glycerol, and certain amino acids.
This allows blood glucose to be maintained even when dietary carbohydrate intake is substantially reduced.
Ketogenesis: Using Fat-Derived Fuel
When carbohydrate availability decreases, the liver increases production of ketone bodies, primarily beta-hydroxybutyrate and acetoacetate.
These ketones serve as alternative fuels for the brain and other tissues.
During sustained nutritional ketosis, the brain can obtain a substantial proportion of its energy from ketones, reducing its requirement for glucose.
Importantly, women possess the same fundamental glucose-producing and ketone-utilizing pathways as men.
There are essential amino acids and essential fatty acids, but no established essential dietary carbohydrate in the same biochemical sense.
This does not mean that carbohydrate-containing foods lack nutritional value, nor does it establish that eliminating carbohydrates produces optimal health outcomes.
It does, however, challenge the claim that women inherently require substantial carbohydrate consumption simply because they are women.
2. Why Ketogenic Nutrition May Benefit Women’s Metabolic Health
Ketogenic diets substantially reduce dietary carbohydrate intake, encouraging greater reliance on fatty acids and ketones for energy.
In appropriately selected individuals, carbohydrate restriction may improve:
Blood glucose regulation.
Insulin resistance and associated metabolic abnormalities.
Appetite control and weight management.
Triglyceride levels.
Certain metabolic and reproductive features associated with insulin resistance.
These potential benefits are particularly relevant to women with polycystic ovary syndrome (PCOS), also described in emerging terminology as polyendocrine metabolic ovarian syndrome (PMOS).
PCOS is frequently associated with insulin resistance, elevated androgen activity, menstrual irregularities, and impaired ovulation.
Excess insulin can contribute to ovarian androgen production and alter sex-hormone regulation.
Reducing dietary carbohydrate intake can lower postprandial glucose exposure and insulin demand, potentially improving metabolic regulation.
Small clinical studies of ketogenic dietary interventions in women with PCOS have reported improvements in insulin resistance, body composition, and certain reproductive and hormonal measurements.
These findings are encouraging, although larger and longer clinical trials are needed to determine how much benefit derives specifically from ketosis rather than weight loss, calorie reduction, or other dietary changes.
Nevertheless, they provide an important counterargument to the assertion that ketogenic nutrition necessarily damages women’s hormonal health.
3. Must Women Remain in Ketosis Continuously?
Not necessarily.
An important concept discussed in the new preprint is intermittent ketogenic nutrition.
Instead of remaining in continuous nutritional ketosis, individuals might periodically alternate between ketogenic and less carbohydrate-restricted eating patterns.
The goal is to investigate metabolic flexibility—the ability to adapt fuel utilization according to nutritional and physiological conditions.
This may offer an alternative for individuals who find continuous strict ketogenic diets difficult to maintain.
For people with significant insulin resistance or type 2 diabetes, more sustained carbohydrate restriction may offer better short-term glycemic control, although medications and metabolic responses require monitoring.
In cancer, ketogenic diets are also being investigated as potential adjuncts to conventional treatment. However, improved cancer survival from ketogenic interventions has not been established in rigorous clinical trials, and cancer patients may be particularly vulnerable to weight loss and malnutrition.
Intermittent ketogenic nutrition remains a promising research hypothesis, not an established superior or universally safer dietary protocol.
Its frequency, duration, nutritional composition, and long-term health effects require further investigation.
4. Are Reported Ketogenic Side Effects Really Caused by Ketosis?
This question deserves greater scientific attention, especially in women.
Some women report fatigue, headaches, sleep disturbances, constipation, hair loss, menstrual changes, mood disturbances, or reduced exercise performance after beginning ketogenic diets.
These experiences are real and should not be dismissed.
But observing a symptom during ketosis does not automatically establish that ketosis itself caused the symptom.
Several overlapping factors deserve consideration.
A. Electrolyte Depletion and Dehydration
During the early stages of carbohydrate restriction, reduced insulin levels and changes in glycogen storage can increase renal sodium and water losses.
This may contribute to headaches, weakness, dizziness, muscle cramps, and fatigue.
Such effects may arise from altered fluid and electrolyte balance rather than a direct harmful effect of ketones.
However, sodium and electrolyte replacement should be individualized, particularly in people with kidney disease, heart failure, hypertension, or relevant medication use.
B. Micronutrient Deficiencies
A poorly formulated ketogenic diet may fail to provide sufficient vitamins and minerals.
For example:
Magnesium: Inadequate intake can contribute to fatigue, muscle cramps, and neuromuscular symptoms.
Iron: Iron deficiency is particularly relevant to menstruating women and can produce fatigue, hair loss, and impaired exercise tolerance.
Iodine and selenium: These nutrients are important for thyroid function, although excess supplementation can also cause harm.
B vitamins: Deficiencies may affect energy metabolism, neurological function, and general health.
Vitamin C: Essential for collagen synthesis, antioxidant defense, carnitine biosynthesis, and several other physiological processes.
A low-carbohydrate diet can be nutritionally adequate, but this depends on food selection and, where appropriate, individualized supplementation.
The important question is whether symptoms reflect ketosis, inadequate nutritional intake, or both.
C. Inadequate Calories and Protein
Many people spontaneously eat less after reducing carbohydrates.
While this can benefit weight management in some individuals, excessive energy restriction may create problems, particularly for lean or physically active women.
Low energy availability can disrupt reproductive hormone signaling, impair exercise recovery, and contribute to menstrual irregularities.
This is recognized in the literature on relative energy deficiency in sport.
Importantly, low carbohydrate availability may also have physiological effects independent of total calorie deficiency in some athletic settings.
Therefore, neither carbohydrate restriction nor inadequate caloric intake should be automatically excluded as a contributing factor.
A sustainable nutritional program must provide sufficient energy and appropriate protein.
D. Thyroid Function, Menopause, and Other Medical Conditions
Symptoms such as fatigue, cold intolerance, sleep disturbances, menstrual irregularities, and hair loss can arise from multiple causes.
These include thyroid disorders, iron-deficiency anemia, menopause-related hormonal changes, chronic illness, excessive exercise, medication effects, and sleep disturbances.
When symptoms appear during dietary changes, clinicians should investigate these possibilities rather than assuming one explanation.
E. Environmental Toxicants: An Underexplored Possibility
Certain persistent environmental pollutants accumulate in adipose tissue.
During substantial weight loss, circulating concentrations of some fat-stored pollutants can increase as adipose tissue is mobilized.
This raises a research question: Could changes in circulating environmental pollutants influence symptoms during major dietary and weight-loss interventions?
The possibility deserves investigation, particularly within systems-oriented research.
However, there is currently insufficient evidence to conclude that pollutant mobilization explains typical ketogenic-diet symptoms in women.
Nor does this observation establish a need for detoxification therapies.
Controlled research is necessary to determine whether changes in pollutant concentrations produce clinically meaningful effects.
F. Genuine Diet-Related Adverse Effects Must Also Be Recognized
Not every adverse effect has an alternative explanation.
Ketogenic dietary patterns can cause constipation and gastrointestinal complaints. Some individuals experience substantial elevations in LDL cholesterol or apolipoprotein B (ApoB).
Carbohydrate restriction may also reduce performance during certain high-intensity athletic activities.
And people using insulin, sulfonylureas, or SGLT2 inhibitors may face important medication-related risks.
The goal should not be to dismiss adverse effects, but to identify their actual causes.
A scientific approach investigates both the benefits and possible harms of ketogenic nutrition instead of assuming either universal safety or universal danger.
5. The Insulin–Cortisol–Vitamin C Axis: A Broader Explanation
One of the major themes in our Integrative Orthomolecular Systems Medicine (I-OM) research is that human metabolism cannot be understood by examining dietary carbohydrates alone.
Our previously published Insulin–Cortisol–Vitamin C (ICV) framework proposes a systems-level model integrating metabolic regulation, stress physiology, and micronutrient status.
The framework considers three interconnected components.
Insulin: Metabolic and Hormonal Regulation
Insulin regulates glucose handling, nutrient storage, and multiple processes affecting reproductive and metabolic health.
Insulin resistance can influence ovarian androgen production, sex-hormone-binding globulin, and other hormonal pathways.
Carbohydrate restriction may improve insulin-related parameters in selected individuals, especially those with insulin resistance.
Cortisol: Stress and Metabolic Adaptation
Cortisol participates in glucose production, stress adaptation, immune regulation, and energy mobilization.
Its effects depend on physiological context, including sleep, physical activity, nutritional status, illness, and psychological stress.
A woman following a nutritionally adequate ketogenic diet may respond differently from one combining severe energy restriction, inadequate recovery, and sustained physiological stress.
Vitamin C: Nutritional and Redox Support
Vitamin C supports antioxidant defense, collagen and carnitine synthesis, catecholamine production, and normal physiological function.
The ICV framework proposes that vitamin C status may influence aspects of metabolic and hormonal adaptation.
However, it remains a research hypothesis rather than a validated method for predicting ketogenic-diet outcomes, and evidence does not establish that high-dose vitamin C prevents reproductive disturbances caused by carbohydrate restriction.
The broader lesson is that dietary responses may depend on multiple interacting variables.
A person’s response to ketogenic nutrition may reflect insulin sensitivity, energy intake, stress physiology, nutrient adequacy, medication use, and underlying health—not carbohydrate consumption alone.
This systems-level perspective provides testable questions for future research.
Related scientific paper:
Cheng, R. Z., Levy, T. E., and Hunninghake, R. (2025). The Insulin–Cortisol–Vitamin C Axis: A Missing Regulatory Framework in Metabolic and Hormonal Homeostasis—A Narrative Review.
Read the ICV framework preprint: https://doi.org/10.20944/preprints202512.0217.v3
6. What About Pregnancy, Breastfeeding, and Older Women?
The absence of an essential dietary carbohydrate requirement does not establish universal ketogenic-diet safety.
Pregnancy involves substantial changes in maternal metabolism, fetal development, and nutritional requirements. Current evidence does not support routine ketogenic dieting during pregnancy or lactation without specialized clinical evaluation.
Likewise, children and adolescents have important nutritional requirements for growth and development. Therapeutic ketogenic diets are used for selected medical conditions under specialist supervision, but should not be generalized to all children.
In older women, carbohydrate restriction may help manage certain metabolic conditions. However, maintaining adequate protein, energy, micronutrients, and muscle mass is particularly important.
Women with eating disorders, certain inherited metabolic disorders, or complex medical conditions may need to avoid ketogenic diets or pursue different strategies.
Sex alone should not dictate carbohydrate requirements, but age, reproductive status, health conditions, and individual physiology matter.
7. What Does a Well-Formulated Ketogenic Approach Look Like?
For adults considering ketogenic nutrition, the emphasis should be on nutritional adequacy rather than carbohydrate restriction alone.
Important principles include:
Adequate calories and high-quality protein to maintain muscle and physiological function.
Appropriate sources of dietary fat, with attention to lipid responses and cardiovascular risk.
Sufficient vitamins, minerals, and electrolytes from food and, when clinically indicated, supplementation.
Monitoring metabolic health, symptoms, and medication requirements.
Individual adjustment based on reproductive status, physical activity, medical conditions, and tolerance.
Evaluation of persistent symptoms rather than automatically attributing them to ketosis—or dismissing them as harmless adaptation.
Ketone levels can confirm nutritional ketosis, but higher ketone levels do not necessarily mean better health outcomes.
For people using glucose-lowering medications, professional guidance may be necessary before substantial carbohydrate restriction.
8. The I-OM Perspective: Beyond the Carbohydrate Debate
The familiar debate is often framed too simply:
Do women need carbohydrates, or should women avoid them?
A better scientific question is:
How do we optimize women’s metabolic health while accounting for insulin regulation, energy availability, hormonal physiology, nutritional status, and individual responses?
Human evolution demonstrates considerable dietary and metabolic adaptability.
Biochemistry confirms that both women and men can produce glucose and utilize ketones.
Clinical research suggests that ketogenic diets may offer meaningful benefits for selected women, especially those with insulin resistance and PCOS.
At the same time, long-term outcomes, reproductive effects, cardiovascular safety, and the relative merits of intermittent versus continuous ketosis require further study.
The I-OM approach emphasizes identifying underlying contributors to metabolic dysfunction and creating nutritionally adequate, individually appropriate interventions.
This means avoiding two equally unscientific assumptions:
That women universally require high-carbohydrate diets for hormonal health.
That ketogenic nutrition is automatically safe or optimal for every woman.
Our working hypothesis is that nutritional adequacy, metabolic health, stress physiology, and individual circumstances may explain much of the variation in women’s responses to carbohydrate restriction.
That hypothesis deserves rigorous clinical testing.
9. Conclusion: Women Need Adequate Nutrition, Not Necessarily High Carbohydrate Intake
Women do not have a scientifically established, universal requirement for high dietary carbohydrate intake simply because they are women.
Their bodies possess the same fundamental mechanisms of gluconeogenesis, fat oxidation, and ketone utilization as those of men.
Ketogenic nutrition may provide metabolic advantages in selected populations, including women with insulin resistance and PCOS.
Furthermore, symptoms occurring during ketogenic dieting should prompt investigation of nutritional inadequacies, electrolyte disturbances, insufficient energy availability, medications, medical conditions, and other potential contributors.
But genuine diet-related harms must also be recognized.
The goal is not to pursue ketosis at any cost.
It is to support metabolic health, hormonal function, nutritional adequacy, and long-term well-being.
Women need glucose—but they do not necessarily need to eat carbohydrates to obtain it.
And perhaps most importantly:
Women’s metabolic health deserves better science than blanket dietary rules based on sex alone.
Scientific Sources and Further Reading
Featured research preprint
Cheng, R. Z. (2026). Ketogenic and Intermittent Ketogenic Diets in Women: Evolutionary Foundations, Metabolic Flexibility, Sex-Specific Physiology, and Applications of the Insulin–Cortisol–Vitamin C Framework.
Preprints.org, October 20, 2026.
https://www.preprints.org/manuscript/202610.1932
Related ICV framework publication
Cheng, R. Z., Levy, T. E., and Hunninghake, R. (2025). The Insulin–Cortisol–Vitamin C Axis: A Missing Regulatory Framework in Metabolic and Hormonal Homeostasis—A Narrative Review.
https://doi.org/10.20944/preprints202512.0217.v3
For clinical studies, scientific references, and detailed discussion of competing hypotheses and research limitations, readers are encouraged to consult the full preprint.
About OMNS Global
Orthomolecular Medicine News Service (OMNS) Global promotes scientific discussion and public education concerning orthomolecular medicine, nutrition, metabolic health, micronutrients, and integrative approaches to health and disease.
OMNS Global and the I-OM Systems Medicine community encourage critical examination of metabolic, nutritional, hormonal, and environmental factors that may influence human health.
Explore the I-OM Systems Medicine community: https://community.i-om.ai
Learn more about I-OM: https://i-om.ai
Medical disclaimer: This article is intended for scientific discussion and public education. It does not constitute individualized medical advice. Ketogenic diets may be unsuitable for certain individuals or require professional monitoring, particularly during pregnancy, lactation, childhood, or treatment with glucose-lowering medications.
Disclosure: Adapted from the author’s scientific preprint posted on MDPI-supported Preprints.org. The preprint has not undergone peer review.
Richard Z. Cheng, MD, PhD | October 2026 | Public Health Education
Editor’s Note This article was prepared in part as a scientific and educational foundation for the author’s presentation, “The Insulin–Cortisol–Vitamin C Axis: A Systems-Based Regulatory Framework,” at A4M LongevityFest 2026 (December 11–13, Las Vegas).
[image]
A4M LongevityFest 2026 — speaker announcement
The presentation will explore the interactions and interdependence among insulin regulation, cortisol-mediated stress responses, and vitamin C physiology through the proposed Insulin–Cortisol–Vitamin C (ICV) Axis, with implications for metabolic health, healthy aging, and particularly bioidentical hormone replacement therapy (BHRT) and women’s hormonal health.
A central theme is that low-carbohydrate/metabolic medicine and orthomolecular medicine provide essential physiological foundations for functional and longevity medicine. Hormonal optimization, including BHRT, should not be pursued in isolation from underlying metabolic and micronutrient status. This integrated perspective—“Beyond BHRT: The Missing Metabolic and Orthomolecular Foundations of Hormonal Health”—reflects a core principle of Integrative Orthomolecular Systems Medicine (I-OM): lasting health requires coordinated attention to metabolic, nutritional, and hormonal regulation.
Preprint source: “Ketogenic and Intermittent Ketogenic Diets in Women: Evolutionary Foundations, Metabolic Flexibility, Sex-Specific Physiology, and Applications of the Insulin–Cortisol–Vitamin C Framework” (October 20, 2026). https://www.preprints.org/manuscript/202610.1932. This preprint has not undergone peer review.
If Women Must Eat Carbohydrates, How Did Humanity Survive Before Agriculture?
We frequently hear that women need carbohydrates to maintain healthy hormones, regular menstrual cycles, fertility, and reproductive health. Some even suggest that ketogenic diets are fundamentally unsuitable for women.
But is this biologically justified?
Consider human evolutionary history.
Modern humans have existed for approximately 300,000 years, while our evolutionary ancestors go back millions of years. Agriculture began only about 12,000 years ago.
For the overwhelming majority of human evolutionary history, people depended on hunting, fishing, and gathering rather than cultivated grains and modern processed foods.
Carbohydrate availability differed dramatically across environments. Tropical populations might have access to fruits, tubers, roots, and honey, while populations in colder environments or during certain seasons might have substantially fewer carbohydrate sources.
Yet human populations survived and reproduced.
Women conceived, carried pregnancies, gave birth, and breastfed long before agriculture became widespread.
This raises an important question:
If substantial dietary carbohydrate intake were universally essential for female reproductive health, how did women reproduce across environments where carbohydrate availability was limited?
This evolutionary argument does not establish that all prehistoric humans ate ketogenic diets. Archaeological and anthropological research demonstrates that carbohydrate-rich plant foods also contributed importantly to many ancestral diets.
What evolution demonstrates is something broader: humans developed considerable flexibility in obtaining and utilizing metabolic fuels.
And this flexibility exists in both women and men.
1. The Human Body Needs Glucose—but Not Necessarily Dietary Carbohydrates
Glucose is essential for several physiological functions. Red blood cells, for example, depend on glucose because they lack mitochondria.
However, glucose does not have to come directly from dietary carbohydrates.
The body possesses two remarkable metabolic adaptations.
Gluconeogenesis: Manufacturing Our Own Glucose
The liver and kidneys can manufacture glucose from substrates including lactate, glycerol, and certain amino acids.
This allows blood glucose to be maintained even when dietary carbohydrate intake is substantially reduced.
Ketogenesis: Using Fat-Derived Fuel
When carbohydrate availability decreases, the liver increases production of ketone bodies, primarily beta-hydroxybutyrate and acetoacetate.
These ketones serve as alternative fuels for the brain and other tissues.
During sustained nutritional ketosis, the brain can obtain a substantial proportion of its energy from ketones, reducing its requirement for glucose.
Importantly, women possess the same fundamental glucose-producing and ketone-utilizing pathways as men.
There are essential amino acids and essential fatty acids, but no established essential dietary carbohydrate in the same biochemical sense.
This does not mean that carbohydrate-containing foods lack nutritional value, nor does it establish that eliminating carbohydrates produces optimal health outcomes.
It does, however, challenge the claim that women inherently require substantial carbohydrate consumption simply because they are women.
2. Why Ketogenic Nutrition May Benefit Women’s Metabolic Health
Ketogenic diets substantially reduce dietary carbohydrate intake, encouraging greater reliance on fatty acids and ketones for energy.
In appropriately selected individuals, carbohydrate restriction may improve:
Blood glucose regulation.
Insulin resistance and associated metabolic abnormalities.
Appetite control and weight management.
Triglyceride levels.
Certain metabolic and reproductive features associated with insulin resistance.
These potential benefits are particularly relevant to women with polycystic ovary syndrome (PCOS), also described in emerging terminology as polyendocrine metabolic ovarian syndrome (PMOS).
PCOS is frequently associated with insulin resistance, elevated androgen activity, menstrual irregularities, and impaired ovulation.
Excess insulin can contribute to ovarian androgen production and alter sex-hormone regulation.
Reducing dietary carbohydrate intake can lower postprandial glucose exposure and insulin demand, potentially improving metabolic regulation.
Small clinical studies of ketogenic dietary interventions in women with PCOS have reported improvements in insulin resistance, body composition, and certain reproductive and hormonal measurements.
These findings are encouraging, although larger and longer clinical trials are needed to determine how much benefit derives specifically from ketosis rather than weight loss, calorie reduction, or other dietary changes.
Nevertheless, they provide an important counterargument to the assertion that ketogenic nutrition necessarily damages women’s hormonal health.
3. Must Women Remain in Ketosis Continuously?
Not necessarily.
An important concept discussed in the new preprint is intermittent ketogenic nutrition.
Instead of remaining in continuous nutritional ketosis, individuals might periodically alternate between ketogenic and less carbohydrate-restricted eating patterns.
The goal is to investigate metabolic flexibility—the ability to adapt fuel utilization according to nutritional and physiological conditions.
This may offer an alternative for individuals who find continuous strict ketogenic diets difficult to maintain.
For people with significant insulin resistance or type 2 diabetes, more sustained carbohydrate restriction may offer better short-term glycemic control, although medications and metabolic responses require monitoring.
In cancer, ketogenic diets are also being investigated as potential adjuncts to conventional treatment. However, improved cancer survival from ketogenic interventions has not been established in rigorous clinical trials, and cancer patients may be particularly vulnerable to weight loss and malnutrition.
Intermittent ketogenic nutrition remains a promising research hypothesis, not an established superior or universally safer dietary protocol.
Its frequency, duration, nutritional composition, and long-term health effects require further investigation.
4. Are Reported Ketogenic Side Effects Really Caused by Ketosis?
This question deserves greater scientific attention, especially in women.
Some women report fatigue, headaches, sleep disturbances, constipation, hair loss, menstrual changes, mood disturbances, or reduced exercise performance after beginning ketogenic diets.
These experiences are real and should not be dismissed.
But observing a symptom during ketosis does not automatically establish that ketosis itself caused the symptom.
Several overlapping factors deserve consideration.
A. Electrolyte Depletion and Dehydration
During the early stages of carbohydrate restriction, reduced insulin levels and changes in glycogen storage can increase renal sodium and water losses.
This may contribute to headaches, weakness, dizziness, muscle cramps, and fatigue.
Such effects may arise from altered fluid and electrolyte balance rather than a direct harmful effect of ketones.
However, sodium and electrolyte replacement should be individualized, particularly in people with kidney disease, heart failure, hypertension, or relevant medication use.
B. Micronutrient Deficiencies
A poorly formulated ketogenic diet may fail to provide sufficient vitamins and minerals.
For example:
Magnesium: Inadequate intake can contribute to fatigue, muscle cramps, and neuromuscular symptoms.
Iron: Iron deficiency is particularly relevant to menstruating women and can produce fatigue, hair loss, and impaired exercise tolerance.
Iodine and selenium: These nutrients are important for thyroid function, although excess supplementation can also cause harm.
B vitamins: Deficiencies may affect energy metabolism, neurological function, and general health.
Vitamin C: Essential for collagen synthesis, antioxidant defense, carnitine biosynthesis, and several other physiological processes.
A low-carbohydrate diet can be nutritionally adequate, but this depends on food selection and, where appropriate, individualized supplementation.
The important question is whether symptoms reflect ketosis, inadequate nutritional intake, or both.
C. Inadequate Calories and Protein
Many people spontaneously eat less after reducing carbohydrates.
While this can benefit weight management in some individuals, excessive energy restriction may create problems, particularly for lean or physically active women.
Low energy availability can disrupt reproductive hormone signaling, impair exercise recovery, and contribute to menstrual irregularities.
This is recognized in the literature on relative energy deficiency in sport.
Importantly, low carbohydrate availability may also have physiological effects independent of total calorie deficiency in some athletic settings.
Therefore, neither carbohydrate restriction nor inadequate caloric intake should be automatically excluded as a contributing factor.
A sustainable nutritional program must provide sufficient energy and appropriate protein.
D. Thyroid Function, Menopause, and Other Medical Conditions
Symptoms such as fatigue, cold intolerance, sleep disturbances, menstrual irregularities, and hair loss can arise from multiple causes.
These include thyroid disorders, iron-deficiency anemia, menopause-related hormonal changes, chronic illness, excessive exercise, medication effects, and sleep disturbances.
When symptoms appear during dietary changes, clinicians should investigate these possibilities rather than assuming one explanation.
E. Environmental Toxicants: An Underexplored Possibility
Certain persistent environmental pollutants accumulate in adipose tissue.
During substantial weight loss, circulating concentrations of some fat-stored pollutants can increase as adipose tissue is mobilized.
This raises a research question: Could changes in circulating environmental pollutants influence symptoms during major dietary and weight-loss interventions?
The possibility deserves investigation, particularly within systems-oriented research.
However, there is currently insufficient evidence to conclude that pollutant mobilization explains typical ketogenic-diet symptoms in women.
Nor does this observation establish a need for detoxification therapies.
Controlled research is necessary to determine whether changes in pollutant concentrations produce clinically meaningful effects.
F. Genuine Diet-Related Adverse Effects Must Also Be Recognized
Not every adverse effect reported during ketogenic dieting is necessarily caused by ketosis itself. Dietary formulation, nutritional adequacy, metabolic adaptation, and underlying physiological conditions must be carefully considered.
Gastrointestinal effects. A properly formulated ketogenic diet is high in fat, very low in carbohydrates, and adequate in protein. Its substantial fat content may promote bowel movements and, in some individuals, cause loose stools or diarrhea, particularly when fat intake exceeds digestive tolerance. Constipation is not an inherent consequence of ketosis and may instead reflect inadequate hydration, electrolyte imbalance, insufficient food intake, or other contributing factors. Nevertheless, constipation can occur even with well-formulated ketogenic diets.
Lipid changes. Some individuals experience substantial elevations in LDL cholesterol or apolipoprotein B (ApoB). These responses may vary with dietary fat composition, genetics, weight changes, and underlying metabolic characteristics. Elevated ApoB warrants appropriate cardiovascular risk assessment rather than automatic dismissal.
Exercise performance and metabolic adaptation. Reduced performance during high-intensity exercise has been reported in some individuals following carbohydrate-restricted diets. However, such observations should not automatically be attributed to ketosis itself. Inadequate caloric or protein intake, electrolyte and micronutrient insufficiencies, incomplete metabolic adaptation, and underlying disturbances in cellular energy metabolism may contribute. The specific physiological demands of high-intensity exercise and the potential effects of reduced carbohydrate availability must also be considered. Carefully controlled studies are needed to distinguish these factors.
Medication-related risks. Individuals taking insulin or sulfonylureas may develop hypoglycemia when carbohydrate intake is substantially reduced without appropriate medication adjustment. Those taking SGLT2 inhibitors face an increased risk of euglycemic ketoacidosis, a potentially serious complication requiring particular caution.
The central scientific question is not merely whether an adverse symptom occurs during ketogenic dieting, but what actually causes it.
An Integrative Orthomolecular Systems Medicine (I-OM) approach investigates dietary composition, nutritional and micronutrient adequacy, electrolyte balance, metabolic adaptation, medication effects, and underlying physiological dysfunction before attributing symptoms directly to ketosis.
The objective is neither to dismiss genuine adverse effects nor to assume that ketogenic nutrition is inherently harmful. Rather, it is to identify modifiable contributing factors, recognize risks intrinsic to particular dietary or metabolic conditions, and optimize nutritional strategies for safety, physiological function, and long-term metabolic health.
5. The Insulin–Cortisol–Vitamin C Axis: Why Metabolic, Nutritional, and Hormonal Balance Must Be Considered Together
A central principle of Integrative Orthomolecular Systems Medicine (I-OM) is that insulin regulation, stress physiology, and micronutrient-dependent biological functions are interconnected. Improving one component may not fully address dysfunction in the others.
The Insulin–Cortisol–Vitamin C (ICV) framework proposes three complementary areas of investigation: low-carbohydrate or ketogenic nutrition for selected metabolic problems; orthomolecular assessment and correction of nutritional insufficiencies; and individualized evaluation of hormonal and stress-related disturbances. These approaches may influence one another, but the framework as a whole remains an investigational explanatory model rather than a validated treatment algorithm.
Insulin: Metabolic and Hormonal Regulation
Insulin regulates blood glucose, nutrient storage, and pathways important to reproductive endocrinology. Insulin resistance and hyperinsulinemia can influence ovarian androgen production and sex-hormone-binding globulin. Appropriate carbohydrate restriction can improve glycemic measures in some patients, particularly those with insulin resistance, type 2 diabetes, or PCOS/PMOS. However, insulin optimization alone may not resolve every hormonal or nutritional problem.
Cortisol: Stress and Endocrine Adaptation
Cortisol participates in glucose production, energy mobilization, circadian adaptation, and immune regulation. Sleep disruption, persistent stress, illness, inadequate energy availability, and other conditions can influence these systems. Cortisol should not be treated as universally harmful: its normal timing and regulation are essential. Clinically relevant endocrine disorders require accurate diagnosis rather than assumptions based on symptoms alone.
Vitamin C: Orthomolecular and Redox Support
Vitamin C is required for collagen and carnitine synthesis, contributes to catecholamine synthesis, and supports normal antioxidant and cellular functions. Magnesium, zinc, iron, iodine, selenium, and B vitamins also participate in metabolism and endocrine physiology. Evaluating inadequate intake or clinically demonstrated deficiency is therefore relevant, especially when symptoms persist during a restrictive dietary intervention. It has not been established that high-dose vitamin C alone normalizes female hormones or prevents adverse responses to ketogenic diets.
The central ICV hypothesis is that dysfunction or insufficiency in one component may influence the others. Its proposed additional clinical value—beyond established metabolic care, indicated nutrition therapy, and appropriate endocrine treatment—requires prospective testing.
Beyond BHRT: Why Hormonal Balance Requires Metabolic and Orthomolecular Balance
Bioidentical Hormone Replacement Therapy (BHRT) is prominent in many Functional Medicine (FM) practices, particularly for menopausal symptoms. Some regulated bioidentical hormone formulations have evidence-based clinical uses; compounded formulations require additional caution because standardization and safety data can differ.
However, hormone-focused approaches may concentrate heavily on measuring and adjusting circulating hormones, including sex hormones and, in some practices, the hypothalamic–pituitary–adrenal (HPA) axis, without adequately addressing the underlying metabolic and nutritional environment.
The ICV framework proposes that clinically relevant hormonal disturbances should not be considered independently of insulin regulation, stress physiology, and micronutrient-dependent cellular function.
These systems interact continuously.
Insulin resistance and hyperinsulinemia can influence ovarian androgen production, sex-hormone-binding globulin (SHBG), and reproductive endocrine function.
Cortisol and HPA-axis regulation interact with glucose metabolism, insulin sensitivity, energy availability, and the physiological stress response.
Vitamin C and other essential micronutrients support biochemical processes involved in hormone synthesis, cellular energy metabolism, redox regulation, and physiological adaptation.
Consequently, identifying and treating an isolated hormonal abnormality may not address all the factors contributing to the patient’s symptoms or metabolic dysfunction.
The I-OM approach proposes integrating individualized hormonal assessment and, when clinically indicated, evidence-based hormone therapy with appropriate carbohydrate restriction, orthomolecular nutritional assessment, and correction of identified metabolic or micronutrient abnormalities.
The objective is not merely to normalize hormone concentrations, but to improve the broader physiological environment in which hormonal regulation occurs.
From PCOS to PMOS: Recognition of a Broader Metabolic–Endocrine Disorder
An important development consistent with this broader perspective is the 2026 international consensus proposal to rename polycystic ovary syndrome (PCOS) as polyendocrine metabolic ovarian syndrome (PMOS). A transition toward implementation is under way; the older term remains widely used.
The new terminology recognizes that the condition is not simply an ovarian disorder. It involves interacting reproductive, endocrine, metabolic, and psychological features, with insulin resistance playing an important role in many affected women.
This consensus initiative reflects a growing recognition that women’s reproductive health cannot be separated from systemic metabolic and hormonal physiology.
The proposed transition from PCOS to PMOS is conceptually consistent with the ICV framework’s emphasis on interconnected metabolic and endocrine systems.
However, the renaming does not constitute independent validation of the ICV hypothesis or establish vitamin C as a specific treatment for PMOS.
Rather, it reinforces the importance of investigating metabolic dysfunction alongside reproductive and hormonal abnormalities.
The I-OM Perspective: Three Interdependent Pillars
Within the proposed ICV framework, comprehensive hormonal health management involves three complementary pillars:
Metabolic optimization: Low-carbohydrate or ketogenic nutrition, where appropriate, to improve insulin regulation and metabolic flexibility.
Orthomolecular optimization: Adequate vitamin C and other essential micronutrients to support biochemical, redox, and cellular functions.
Hormonal optimization: Evaluation and management of clinically relevant endocrine abnormalities; when indicated, consideration of evidence-based menopausal hormone therapy (including regulated bioidentical formulations) alongside appropriate assessment of stress physiology. Hormone treatment should not be assumed to correct insulin resistance or nutritional insufficiency.
A disturbance in one pillar may influence the others, potentially contributing to broader physiological imbalance.
This interconnected perspective helps explain why adjusting hormone levels alone may not resolve every symptom, just as improving insulin regulation alone may not correct underlying nutritional or endocrine abnormalities.
The proposed ICV framework therefore extends conventional hormone-focused management toward a more integrated systems-medicine model.
Its central hypothesis is that coordinated metabolic, nutritional, and hormonal optimization may provide benefits beyond addressing each component in isolation. That additional clinical benefit remains to be established through appropriately designed studies.
Hormonal balance is not simply a matter of hormone replacement. It depends on the broader metabolic and nutritional system in which hormones are produced, regulated, and utilized.
Related scientific paper:
Cheng, R. Z., Levy, T. E., and Hunninghake, R. (2025). The Insulin–Cortisol–Vitamin C Axis: A Missing Regulatory Framework in Metabolic and Hormonal Homeostasis—A Narrative Review.
Read the ICV framework preprint: https://doi.org/10.20944/preprints202512.0217.v3
6. What About Pregnancy, Breastfeeding, and Older Women?
The absence of an essential dietary carbohydrate requirement does not establish universal ketogenic-diet safety.
Pregnancy involves substantial changes in maternal metabolism, fetal development, and nutritional requirements. Current evidence does not support routine ketogenic dieting during pregnancy or lactation without specialized clinical evaluation.
Likewise, children and adolescents have important nutritional requirements for growth and development. Therapeutic ketogenic diets are used for selected medical conditions under specialist supervision, but should not be generalized to all children.
In older women, carbohydrate restriction may help manage certain metabolic conditions. However, maintaining adequate protein, energy, micronutrients, and muscle mass is particularly important.
Women with eating disorders, certain inherited metabolic disorders, or complex medical conditions may need to avoid ketogenic diets or pursue different strategies.
Sex alone should not dictate carbohydrate requirements, but age, reproductive status, health conditions, and individual physiology matter.
7. What Does a Well-Formulated Ketogenic Approach Look Like?
For adults considering ketogenic nutrition, the emphasis should be on nutritional adequacy rather than carbohydrate restriction alone.
Important principles include:
Adequate calories and high-quality protein to maintain muscle and physiological function.
Appropriate sources of dietary fat, with attention to lipid responses and cardiovascular risk.
Sufficient vitamins, minerals, and electrolytes from food and, when clinically indicated, supplementation.
Monitoring metabolic health, symptoms, and medication requirements.
Individual adjustment based on reproductive status, physical activity, medical conditions, and tolerance.
Evaluation of persistent symptoms rather than automatically attributing them to ketosis—or dismissing them as harmless adaptation.
Ketone levels can confirm nutritional ketosis, but higher ketone levels do not necessarily mean better health outcomes.
For people using glucose-lowering medications, professional guidance may be necessary before substantial carbohydrate restriction.
8. The I-OM Perspective: Beyond the Carbohydrate Debate
The familiar debate is often framed too simply:
Do women need carbohydrates, or should women avoid them?
A better scientific question is:
How do we optimize women’s metabolic health while accounting for insulin regulation, energy availability, hormonal physiology, nutritional status, and individual responses?
Human evolution demonstrates considerable dietary and metabolic adaptability.
Biochemistry confirms that both women and men can produce glucose and utilize ketones.
Clinical research suggests that ketogenic diets may offer meaningful benefits for selected women, especially those with insulin resistance and PCOS.
At the same time, long-term outcomes, reproductive effects, cardiovascular safety, and the relative merits of intermittent versus continuous ketosis require further study.
The I-OM approach emphasizes identifying underlying contributors to metabolic dysfunction and creating nutritionally adequate, individually appropriate interventions.
This means avoiding two equally unscientific assumptions:
That women universally require high-carbohydrate diets for hormonal health.
That ketogenic nutrition is automatically safe or optimal for every woman.
Our working hypothesis is that nutritional adequacy, metabolic health, stress physiology, and individual circumstances may explain much of the variation in women’s responses to carbohydrate restriction.
That hypothesis deserves rigorous clinical testing.
9. Conclusion: Ketogenic Nutrition Can Be a Safe and Effective Option for Women When Properly Implemented
Women do not have a scientifically established, universal requirement for high dietary carbohydrate intake simply because they are women. Their bodies possess the same fundamental mechanisms of gluconeogenesis, fat oxidation, and ketone utilization as those of men.
A properly formulated ketogenic diet—high in healthy fats, very low in carbohydrates, and adequate in protein—can be a safe and potentially beneficial nutritional strategy for appropriately selected women. Clinical evidence supports metabolic benefits in certain populations, particularly women with insulin resistance, obesity, type 2 diabetes, and polycystic ovary syndrome (PCOS), now also referred to as polyendocrine metabolic ovarian syndrome (PMOS).
The critical distinction is between ketogenic nutrition itself and how the diet is formulated, implemented, and medically supervised.
Reported difficulties such as fatigue, menstrual irregularities, hair loss, sleep disturbances, or reduced exercise performance should not automatically be attributed to ketosis. They warrant a systematic assessment of caloric and protein adequacy, electrolytes, vitamin and micronutrient status, hormonal regulation, metabolic adaptation, underlying medical conditions, and medication effects. Genuine diet-related adverse effects must also be recognized and appropriately managed.
For women with complex metabolic, hormonal, or medical conditions, ketogenic nutrition is best implemented under the guidance of healthcare professionals with relevant expertise in low-carbohydrate and metabolic medicine, orthomolecular nutrition, and functional medicine. Such multidisciplinary expertise can help ensure nutritional adequacy, appropriate hormonal and metabolic assessment, individualized dietary adjustments, and ongoing monitoring of safety and clinical outcomes.
The Integrative Orthomolecular Systems Medicine (I-OM) approach, informed by the proposed Insulin–Cortisol–Vitamin C (ICV) framework, emphasizes three interconnected foundations:
1. Metabolic optimization through appropriately formulated low-carbohydrate or ketogenic nutrition to improve insulin regulation.
2. Orthomolecular optimization through adequate vitamins, minerals, and other essential nutrients to support cellular metabolism and physiological function.
3. Hormonal optimization through appropriate endocrine assessment, stress management, and evidence-based hormonal treatment, including BHRT when clinically indicated.
These components interact, and inadequacy or dysfunction in one may influence the others. Their coordinated management offers a systems-based approach to women’s metabolic and hormonal health, although the additional clinical benefits predicted by the integrated ICV framework require further investigation.
Importantly, safety cannot be assumed for every woman. Pregnancy, breastfeeding, a history of eating disorders, certain metabolic disorders, and medications such as insulin or SGLT2 inhibitors require particular caution. Lipid responses, including LDL cholesterol and ApoB, should also be monitored when appropriate. Specialized supervision improves the ability to identify and manage risks but does not eliminate them.
The goal is not ketosis at any cost. It is safe, nutritionally complete, physiologically appropriate ketogenic nutrition that supports metabolic health, hormonal function, and long-term well-being.
Women need glucose—but they do not necessarily need to consume dietary carbohydrates to obtain it.
The central message is that ketogenic diets should not be dismissed as inherently unsafe for women. When properly formulated, appropriately selected, individualized, and monitored by qualified healthcare professionals, they can be a valuable therapeutic option.
Women’s metabolic health deserves an integrated, evidence-informed approach—not blanket dietary restrictions or assumptions based on sex alone.
Continue Learning: I-OM Academy Women’s Health and BHRT Certificate Courses
The principles discussed in this article—integrating metabolic health, orthomolecular nutrition, hormonal regulation, and individualized clinical care—are further explored through educational programs offered by I-OM Academy.
1. Women’s Health Essentials Certificate Course
This course provides a structured introduction to women’s health within the Integrative Orthomolecular Systems Medicine (I-OM) perspective, emphasizing the importance of understanding metabolic, nutritional, and hormonal factors together.
Explore the Women’s Health Essentials Certificate Course
2. I-OM Academy Certificate in Bioidentical Hormone Replacement Therapy (BHRT)
This certificate program focuses on BHRT within the broader context of integrative hormonal health. It complements the article’s central theme: hormonal management should be considered alongside metabolic regulation, nutritional adequacy, and relevant physiological factors.
Explore the I-OM Academy BHRT Certificate Course
Beyond BHRT: The Missing Metabolic and Orthomolecular Foundations of Hormonal Health
Together, these educational opportunities encourage a more integrated understanding of women’s health—moving beyond isolated hormone measurements toward consideration of the interconnected metabolic, nutritional, and endocrine systems.
Explore additional educational programs and scientific discussions through I-OM Systems Medicine.
Scientific Sources and Further Reading
Featured research preprint
Cheng, R. Z. (2026). Ketogenic and Intermittent Ketogenic Diets in Women: Evolutionary Foundations, Metabolic Flexibility, Sex-Specific Physiology, and Applications of the Insulin–Cortisol–Vitamin C Framework.
Preprints.org, October 20, 2026.
https://www.preprints.org/manuscript/202610.1932
Related ICV framework publication
Cheng, R. Z., Levy, T. E., and Hunninghake, R. (2025). The Insulin–Cortisol–Vitamin C Axis: A Missing Regulatory Framework in Metabolic and Hormonal Homeostasis—A Narrative Review.
https://doi.org/10.20944/preprints202512.0217.v3
Teede HJ, et al. Polyendocrine metabolic ovarian syndrome, the new name for polycystic ovary syndrome: a multistep global consensus process. The Lancet. 2026;407:2329–2339. Redirecting
For clinical studies, scientific references, and detailed discussion of competing hypotheses and research limitations, readers are encouraged to consult the full preprint.
About OMNS Global
Orthomolecular Medicine News Service (OMNS) Global promotes scientific discussion and public education concerning orthomolecular medicine, nutrition, metabolic health, micronutrients, and integrative approaches to health and disease.
OMNS Global and the I-OM Systems Medicine community encourage critical examination of metabolic, nutritional, hormonal, and environmental factors that may influence human health.
Explore the I-OM Systems Medicine community: https://community.i-om.ai
Learn more about I-OM: https://i-om.ai
Medical disclaimer: This article is intended for scientific discussion and public education. It does not constitute individualized medical advice. Ketogenic diets may be unsuitable for certain individuals or require professional monitoring, particularly during pregnancy, lactation, childhood, or treatment with glucose-lowering medications.
Disclosure: Adapted from the author’s scientific preprint posted on MDPI-supported Preprints.org. The preprint has not undergone peer review.
